XCON meeting notes, 12-Nov-2004: * xcon-bfcp-02 (gonzalo): wants someone to check consistency w/conf framework. Alan J agreed to do that. Gonzalo asking for opinions on authentication. agreed to what Gonzalo had on the slide, with proviso that if TLS isn't used then something with comparable characteristics (e.g. ipsec) should be used. Re transactions, there is no timeout proposed - just request/response over tcp. Agreed to keep as is. Re several ongoing floor requests by same client - question if this is ok. There were no objections raised. Request for volunteers to review the draft. Got Mary Barnes, Ben Campbell, Miguel, Hisham Kartabile, Dave Morgan, Bob Hughes, Christer Homberg. Discussion of floor ids in SDP and relation to media. Cullen wanted to have multiple floors for same media. Alan J suggested possibility of floor not associated with any media. Gonzalo said is small change to IANA registration. * draft-ekim-sipping-conf-floor-package-00 (still Gonzalo): richer than BFCP. Provides a simple way to learn of floor status, since server decides when to send notifications. In discussion there was disagreement over the need for this. Gonzalo would like use cases for why this is needed. Place for discussion is xcon, not sipping. Cullen thinks it is inevitable there will be a sip way to do floor control, whether this or something else. * Media Design Team Status: current work incomplete. Current team will disband and discussion will continue on list because there is no longer a distinction between conf policy and media policy. Work ongoing on terminology and framework. Doc splits await that work. Interim meeting planned - probably January - details on list. Alison said do not have approval to do a lot of work in an ad hoc and announce it without conversation on list. That includes restructuring proposed at this meeting. She would prefer that they decide on intended documents even if they don't have the terminology. 3GPP is expecting stuff. Cullen requested statement on the list of what that is. They are certainly expecting a floor control protocol. Expectation to last call that right after the expert review. They also need parts of CPCP, but this needs followup. Hisham says for IMS rel 6 they will need everything in xcon. Adam will get clarification, probably from Keith D and ???.